October 2004
 

 

District 1 Supervisor Candidate: Rose Tsai

As a mother of two school-aged children, I fear for their future. I fear that my two boys will not have the same opportunities I had when I came to this country with my parents back in 1963. I fear they will not be able to get a good education and go to our neighborhood schools. I fear that even if they are lucky enough to get a good education, they will not be able to get a job and live here because those jobs have gone overseas. I fear that my children will have to move out of our beloved City when they are grown because they cannot afford to stay. I fear that when I am old and retired, there will no longer be any Social Security benefits and safety network to rely upon because our government has squander away our tax dollars and mortgaged our future away.

I'm tired of being afraid because our future is too valuable for someone else to waste. Ordinary people like you and me must take a stand and say stop squeezing the working and middle class. Business as usual is not acceptable. If it's not working, then we must change.  If it's not worth it, then we will not pay. Our leadership has failed us so we must look toward ourselves to lead.

Let's start with understanding how we are being led down the wrong path. Look at our bloated $5 billion budget and how City Hall is proposing to solve the financial mess we are in by proposing more taxes. Let's examine the city's policies and propositions on the November ballot.

San Francisco's business community already pays a high price for doing business in the anti-business climate created by our Board of Supervisors. Many large corporations have either left or decided to leave the City in the near future, taking thousands of jobs and tax revenues with them. Small businesses, the backbone of our economy, are now under attack. Two propositions, J and K, will kill our neighborhood businesses.

Proposition K would add yet another cost of doing business by imposing a gross receipts tax of one-tenth of one percent on all businesses with receipts totaling $500,000 or more annually. This might seem to be a rational amount from which to define and exempt small businesses, but you should first realize that this exclusion is calculated on gross receipts, not net receipts (profits). In other words, there is no deduction for salaries and expenses in the calculation and determination of status. Even if a business is losing money, it must pay this tax.

A business could be paying 1.5 percent on its payroll and yet be taxed again on the same payroll because the tax paid cannot be deducted from the gross receipts tax on which the additional one-tenth of one percent is calculated. Proposition K is double taxation for business and grossly unfair. If it isn't illegal, it should be.

According to examples provided by the small business community, a service station's gross receipts are about $6 million annually. A hardware store or property management firm can expect to take in $2 million. In addition to the 1.5 percent payroll tax they already pay, along with high commercial rents and escalating insurance costs, Proposition K seeks to exact another $2,000 - $6,000 annually from these vital members of our community. While $6,000 may not be much to a downtown law firm, this tax, in combination with other increases, such as sewer rates, insurance, worker's compensation and sales taxes, may break a small business.  

November's ballot also features Proposition J, which will increase the sales tax to 8.75 percent, equaling the highest rate in the Bay Area. As evidenced by the empty storefronts in the Richmond, small businesses are already hurting badly in this economy. Let's not make it worse.

If we want our small businesses to stay in San Francisco and thrive, we must vote no on propositions K and J.

Please give me your vote Nov. 2.